The TV newsletter that
tells the truth.
Every new show gets a verdict — drop everything, worth it, background TV, slop, or a war crime. No press releases. No algorithm spin. Just a weekly ruling, delivered Friday morning.
23 issues published. 270 verdicts on the record. The latest one shipped yesterday.
What you get
- A short weekly recap of every meaningful new show on the big six streamers
- A Pick of the Week — one thing actually worth your Saturday
- A running tab of what to skip, and why
What you don’t get
- Press releases rewritten with adjectives
- Ten emails a week
You’re not crazy. Most of it is bad. We’ll tell you which.
The Drop Issue 23: Disney Buys the YouTube Morality Play Guy
Lanterns lands, Ted Lasso returns from the dead, and Disney signs the guy who makes 8-minute lessons.

Disney signed a 20-episode deal with Dhar Mann Studios this week. Dhar Mann. The YouTube guy. The one whose entire catalog is a mean cashier being rude to a homeless man who turns out to be a billionaire, cut to a title card that says Always Be Kind. That guy. Twenty episodes. Bob Iger sat in a room, looked at a slate of possible investments, and said yes to the eight-minute vertical morality play factory. Meanwhile Yahya Abdul-Mateen II is doing press explaining that his Marvel show got un-renewed after being renewed because "it had something to do with the viewership numbers" that Disney wouldn't actually show him. So the plan at the House of Mouse is: kill Wonder Man, fund Dhar Mann. Somewhere in Burbank a strategy deck exists that made this look smart. I would pay real money to read it.
Anyway. Onto the shows.
Lanterns (HBO Max)

Damon Lindelof and Tom King made a Green Lantern show and cast Kyle Chandler as Hal Jordan and Aaron Pierre as John Stewart, and then somebody at HBO looked at the pitch — two space cops investigate a murder in rural America — and greenlit True Detective with a power ring. That's the swing. The pilot dropped Saturday, the cast has Kelly Macdonald and Garret Dillahunt, and Lindelof is on record saying he wanted this to be the anti-Marvel Marvel show, which is the kind of thing showrunners say right before either winning an Emmy or getting quietly reassigned. Early reactions are strong. It's the one thing on the calendar this week that seems to actually want to be something.
✅ WORTH IT
Reacher, Season 4 (Prime Video)

Reacher is back and Alan Ritchson is still shaped like a walking freezer full of chicken. Four seasons in and the formula is untouched: enormous man arrives in town, someone underestimates him, that person's bones are now on a spreadsheet at the hospital. This one drags in Agnez Mo and leans harder into the international-conspiracy stuff, which historically is when the Lee Child books were at their most fun and their least logical. Prime Video knows exactly what it's selling — a guy in a Henley solving problems with his hands — and refuses to overthink it. Bless them for that.
✅ WORTH IT
One email every Friday. Free, unfiltered, and we'll never tell you something is "binge-worthy." Drop your email and we'll do the watching.
What’s trending
isn’t always good.
Today’s top 10, ranked by raw popularity. Anything not already on the docket gets auto-sentenced by the court — trending doesn’t mean it earns the trophy.
Spider-Man: Brand New Day
Cretton ditches the multiverse, hands Holland a lonely NYC Peter, and lets Bernthal's Punisher steal scenes. Actually works.
Nolan's IMAX Odyssey, Damon as Odysseus. First reactions rave, a couple mutter 'easier to respect than love.' Go big screen.
Enormous man walks into town, bones become a spreadsheet. Season four does not overthink it.
Pixar's fifth lap. Jessie leads, Woody & Buzz coast, a haunted iPad shows up. Fine. Your kid won't blink.
The Sheridan formula, unchanged: trauma, tactical vests, helicopter shot every 12 minutes. Works.
Lindelof, King, Chandler, Pierre. Actual grownups made actual choices. The one thing this week that swings.
Dance of the Dragons is fully lit. Matt Smith is a menace. Come back.
Minions in 1920s Hollywood chasing monster-movie creatures. Actually has an idea. Coffin's gibberish still slaps.
Curry Barker's $750K YouTube horror somehow made $400M and a 94 on RT. The cursed wish movie of the summer.
Fourth season and still one of the best sci-fi shows on TV. Ferguson is quietly cooking.
Think the court blew one? Cast a vote →
Has your show been judged?
Search the docket. 270 verdicts and counting. No appeals.
Can’t decide what to watch?
Stop watching slop.
Free forever. Unsubscribe in one click. We'll never sell your email to anyone, mostly because we don't know how.












































